Pasta Bible · Cooking
How to Choose Pasta for Baked Dishes
Think about the first serving before you buy the pasta. If you want to spoon a saucy mixture straight from the dish, choose sturdy short pasta such as rigatoni or penne. For individual portions with a distinct centre, pick jumbo shells or cannelloni that you can fill. For squares that lift out with the layers intact, start with lasagne sheets. Each choice changes where the sauce goes and how much work you do before the dish reaches the oven.
For a spoonful of pasta and sauce together
In a mixed bake, every scoop should bring up pasta and some of what surrounds it. Rigatoni have substantial walls and broad openings. Small pieces of mushroom, meat or vegetable can slip into the tubes as you stir them through sauce. Narrower penne work well with finer pieces. A chunk of vegetable larger than most of the pasta stays outside the tubes, so cut it to a size that sits comfortably on the same fork.
If the topping matters most, think about the baking dish as well as the shape. A broad, shallow layer exposes more pasta to browning. A deeper dish gives more spoonfuls from the softer centre for every crisp edge. Before transferring the pasta, turn it through the sauce in a bowl or pan and inspect a tube from the bottom. Dry interiors and a thick cap of sauce on top usually mean the mixture would benefit from another turn before baking.
Medium conchiglie are another good choice here. Their bowls gather peas, crumbs or small pieces of sauce without anyone having to fill them one at a time. The same outline comes in very different sizes. A bag of small soup shells will make a much finer-textured dish and offers little space for a spoonful of filling.
For a centre you can see when you serve it
A jumbo shell opens like a little boat. You can spoon ricotta and greens into the opening, see how much each shell holds, and lower it into a shallow bed of sauce. Arrange the shells where you want them to finish before covering them as the recipe directs. A wide serving spoon can then lift one or two whole shells onto a plate. Broken shells are still useful in a mixed bake, but a split base is a poor support for a distinct portion of filling.
Cannelloni enclose the centre on all sides. A smooth filling is easier to pipe into a purchased tube than one containing long strands of spinach or large vegetable chunks. If you want that coarser filling, open shells offer easier access. Another approach, when a recipe allows it, is to spread filling on a supple sheet and roll it. Check whether that sheet needs cooking first. A rigid oven-ready sheet will snap if you try to roll it straight from the box.
For lasagne you can cut into portions
Lay a dry sheet in the empty dish to see how its width compares with the base. A pan that fits the sheets with little trimming is convenient. Follow the chosen product's directions for spacing and overlap, since some sheets expand as they take up liquid. Distribute the sauce and filling in even layers, including the corners. A large mound in the middle makes the top sheet tilt, and bare edges can stay hard while the centre cooks.
Check the words on the box before substituting one kind of lasagne for another. Oven-ready sheets rely on moisture from the dish. They need a recipe designed to bring enough liquid into contact with the pasta throughout baking. Other dried sheets may call for boiling first, and a fresh sheet has a different starting moisture again. Switching products while keeping exactly the same liquid and baking sequence can give you dry corners or a loose middle.
For a neat slice, follow the recipe's rest before cutting. Use a knife to separate the portions, including any browned cheese joining them at the top. Slide a broad spatula under the bottom sheet before lifting. If dinner will be spooned from the dish as soon as it comes to the table, a mixed rigatoni bake gives you that freedom without having to preserve layers.
Check what the oven still has to do
A short spell to brown a topping is a different job from a long bake that cooks dry pasta. For a mixed bake, use the recipe's directions for how far to cook the pasta in the pot. The shape needs enough firmness to survive the time it will spend in hot sauce. For filled pasta, it must also withstand handling during assembly. There is no single number of minutes to subtract from the package time for every shape or oven dish.
Baked pasta questions
Can I replace jumbo shells with rigatoni?
For an individually stuffed dish, ordinary rigatoni have much smaller openings. If your filling is soft enough to mix with sauce, you can choose a mixed rigatoni bake and distribute the filling through it. If the appeal is a whole parcel on each plate, look for jumbo shells or a recipe for large filled tubes instead.
Can I buy one shape for both stovetop pasta and a bake?
Ridged penne are a flexible choice for a tomato dressing tonight and a mixed bake another day. Change the cooking point and sauce consistency to fit the next step. If you specifically want cut layers or a generous separate filling, buy the shape for that job.